Join the Neo-Zionist
Revolution!

  • Receive our Kummunique:
    unique and informative emails
    about events, articles, and info
    to keep you in touch.

Kumah Mascots

Kumah Awards

*** THE ALIYAH REVOLUTION ALBUM ***

Friday, February 06, 2009

The Guys Nobody Seems to be Talking About (But Maybe Should)


Lots of buzz is going around between people and definitely in the news about the big players in the upcoming election: Tzipi, Bibi, and Lieberman. Yet not nearly as much is attention is being focused on the forth alternative: Shas. Now before anyone wants to post a comment about how they're all a bunch of crooks I'd like ask why would you single them out? Do you think the other major Knesset parties people would vote for otherwise are squeaky clean? Kadima's head, our current prime minister has just gone through several rounds of indictments and the Prime Minister before him (Sharon) was also tied to some shady deals. And anybody who's had interactions with the government knows that in Israel things with the government are often not quite so "Yashar" as they should be. Plus despite some problems with members in the past, the current head Eli Yishai seems like a fine man and I am not aware of any bad report of him.

Other people want to complain that Shas are all sellouts, they are just interested in money for their causes and nothing else. Well let's take a look at those causes real quick. From what I'm aware of the majority of the money Shas funnels is into religious schools, ways to help educate non-Religious Jews in Jewish knowledge, and other general Torah learning institutions. Chazal says that Hashem created the whole world for the sake of learning Torah... so much so that if there was a moment in which Torah wasn't being learned anywhere in the world it would cease to exist. So for Shas to divert as much money into Torah learning as possible doesn't sound crooked to me, quite the opposite- I would think it would be the best investment this country could make.

Some want to criticize how they obey the directives of Rav Ovadia Yosef and seem to do whatever he says. Well if anyone has something bad to say about Rav Ovadia I would suggest you bite your tongue- for your own sake. This is because he is one our current generation's biggest Talmidei Chachim (if not THE Gadol Hador), and the Gemara's definition of a heretic is one who claims what do we need the rabbis and the Torah scholars for, what good are they?

I ask any right wing religious voter in Israel, or any religious voter for that matter, who would be a better choice? I don't even think I need to explain away Barak or Livni. Bibi? Last time I checked he doesn't sport a kippah on his head too often and he's already proven his diplomatic resolve and love of Eretz Yisrael and our religious heritage by giving away Hevron. If even Sharon didn't have the backbone to stand up against American diplomatic pressure do you really think he's going to?

What about Yisrael Beiteinu? Arutz Sheva recently reported an American diplomat has released a book of his experience dealing with Israel in which he tells that Lieberman once agreed to give in to the PLO's land demands and give away our precious Yesha. Even if he wants to deny this he can't deny things on his official platform like supporting civil marriage. Currently the Rabbinate controls who gets married in this country and Baruch Hashem there is a group responsible enough to make sure Jews are inter-marrying themselves into extinction like they are in America. Baruch Hashem I recently got married here and I can attest that as inconveniant as it may be having about 20 run-ins with the Rabbinut before getting your ketuba, at least they are making certain people are Jewish before letting them marry each other. Now what pray tell do we need civil marriage for in this country if not to allow inter-marriage and gays marrying each other? I asked a campaign worker for Yisrael Beiteinu the other day about this issue. He claimed it is one of the many issues being spun out of control to harm their image and that in truth Lieberman just supports some small concession to allow for tax breaks. This man wore a kippah as does Lieberman, so I ask them, do they believe in the Torah like their clothing suggests or not!?! If G-d explicitly forbids these types of marriages then why do we need to make even small concessions? Every concession one makes in his beliefs highlights a lack of faith in the Torah. And as far as Lieberman trying to advertise himself as the guy to get the arabs out of Israel? Doubtful. Not even Rav Kahane could do that after immeasurable blood sweat and tears, and this guys is no Rav Kahane.

What about Feiglin? I heard him speak at Tuesday Night Live this week and I must say he is about as much of a stand up guy as you'll find. The problem is he is number 36 on the list. In order to get him in you first need to get in 35 shall we say, "not so stand up" people first. He claims this is the only way to change Likud from the inside out. But changes like he is trying to accomplish take time, and in the mean time can we afford to put our hope in a 1 to 35 voting ratio while the future of the country hangs in the balance?

Then there is the Dati Leumi parties. Their hearts are in the right place but it appears as if they can't get their act together long enough to get along with themselves never mind lead the rest of the country. Plus there is the laws of probability that heavily weigh against them gaining enough seats to have serious influence in the government. One could counter that Shas doesn't have a chance of winning the prime ministership either yet that isn't important. Why? It doesn't really matter who is in charge, for we know that on Rosh Hashanah Hashem plans out of that whole following year who will go to war with who, which side will be victorious, and how much money every person and country will have as well as who will live and who will die. Therefore we could vote in the best party and prime minister in the world and if Hashem doesn't help us then we won't have a chance. Likewise we could have the most inept losers at the helm and if Hashem wills it then we'll be successful. Shas isn't going to be the biggest party, that's a given. But what is also almost guaranteed is that they will be big enough that whichever party does lead will have to take them in as a coalition partner. Therefore the stronger they are, the more muscle they have to get what they want- i.e. money to support Torah (something ever so vital now that much of the American philanthropy to Israel is getting hit hard from the world financial crisis). So if Hashem decides who successful we're going to be at war and diplomacy and the like who does it matter who "appears" to be in charge? What we should worry about is how we can affect thigns we do have control over like how many Jews are going to learn Torah or do Teshuva and have a support network to ease them into the religious world when they do.

Now at the end of the day I don't know how much my opinion counts because I am not yet able to vote here anyway. But I will say this, if you look around at all the political posters it's all attacks from this one on that one and counter-attacks the other way. Then you see the egged bus come by with a big picture of Rav Ovadia and it has a blessing to Am Yisrael or a quote from the Tanach, and always something optimistic. If nothing else, let's go with the "glass half full" people!

Labels: , , , , ,







3 Comments:

  • At 12:43 PM , Blogger Malkah said...

    Ah, my Sephardiphiliac and G-d fearing friend, I so appreciate your loving and Torah-centered approach to these elections. And yet I cannot share your conclusions.

    Despite the Torah sagacity of Rav Ovadia, and their constant emphasis on providing for the poor and for Torah institutions, I am sometimes shocked by the inconsistencies between their message and their actions.

    Why did Rav Ovadia recently state that anyone who votes for Lieberman has no share in the world to come?

    Why did they remain in the government in 2005, when retiring would have meant a certain death for the Gush Katif Expulsion?

    Why do they claim support for Torah institutions, yet remain flexible to anti-Torah policies, such as forcibly removing Jews from Judea and Samaria?

    I would love good answers to these questions. I would love reasons to forgive Shas - really. If you can soothe my angry soul, I hope you will try.

     
  • At 10:02 AM , Blogger Unknown said...

    Very strong kashas :)

    From what I understood from an article about Rav Ovadia's recent comments on Lieberman (I think it was in Ynet) it seemed he was worked up mainly over Lieberman supporting civil marriage and wanting to force yeshiva students into army service.

    We both know how utterly helpless the intermarriage situation is in America where half the time you can't even tell who is really Jewish or not. Plus I don't want to sound like a bigot but let's not kid ourselves, we know what the Torah explicitly says about gays (sometimes the Gemara spares even less politeness), and to allow gay marriage in Israel in a time when we are facing daily rocket attacks and nuclear threats G-d forbid is just one chillul Hashem more than I think we can afford right now.

    As far as forcing yeshiva boys to join the army this directly goes against a halacha instituted by none other than Israel's most famous and brave soldier and commander- King David. When he went to fight the band of marauders and some of his soldiers stayed behind, the ones that went to fight didn't want to share the victory spoils with them. King David declared that they all share the spoils equally because when some of the Jewish people go out to war and the others stay back to daven and learn Torah they all play an integral if not equal part in meriting the victory in G-d's eyes.

    As far as Gush Katif, I'm not so sure on that one. I guess a key question would be to ask, did Shas actually vote to support it or just not leave the government to stop it? Because as far as I'm aware many if not most of Likud Kadima and Labor spared no votes in support.

    Rav Ovadia is probably our biggest posek in Eretz Yisrael today if not the world. Therefore his psak halacha carries heavy weight. From what I am aware of I believe he holds that you not only are allowed to but must give away land if you can prove it will save Jewish lives. The key here is showing it will save Jewish lives. I'll be the first to declare that the more land we give, the more lives we lose G-d forbid.

    So the halacha is clear. The question is whether or not Rav Ovadia felt leaving Gush Katif would save lives. I feel like he was very against the move to leave Gaza as I've read on the internet (not always the best source but hey) that he said America suffered hurricane Katrina because of forcing Israel to leave Gaza and I also so a video clip of him talking about Ariel Sharon in regards to the Gaza pullout and seeming to give a curse the likes of which I'm not going to repeat but it was very chilling.

    So if Shas was so against it why didn't they leave the government in that case? I don't know the answer to that. It's complicated but I will say this- if you're going to vote I say vote based on what seems practical, not just what feels right emotionally. Just because you feel somebody burned you and it hurts, doesn't mean that if you look at it logically they might not be the best choice. I dream more than anybody of a candidate who will ride on top of the bomb as it sails into Gaza City or Terhan (Dr. Strangelove style) but my logical mind tells me Shas is the way to go. The success or failure of this country is in the hands of Hashem and Hashem deals with us based on how much Torah we learn and how well we obey it. They just seem like the party that will bring the most Torah into Israel and therefore invoke the most amount of compassion for us on the part of Hashem.

     
  • At 10:11 AM , Blogger Unknown said...

    Also just saw this on Arutz Sheva:

    http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/129824

    Shas MK named "Most Zionistic"

     

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home